epistler: (Default)
[personal profile] epistler posting in [community profile] antishurtugal_reborn

Well, here we go again. Seven frigging years since Inheritance came out, Paolini finally returned to Alaglag. The fans must have been ecstatic. Apparently this is the first in a series of books of short stories, or “Tales of Arglefart”, so we can eventually expect more volumes. And since this is Paolini we’re talking about, the key word here is “eventually”. Rarely has an author used so much time to produce so little. Or so many words to say so little. The book I dubbed “the WormFork book”  is a measly 129 pages long, and almost one hundred percent content free. It doesn’t resolve any major mysteries, it doesn’t tell us anything new about any of the characters with the possible exception of Angela (and in the latter case that’s really not to the good). Whatever else this thing is, it’s most definitely not the Book Five people have been demanding for half a decade and counting.

It’s also the publishing debut of Angela Paolini, something that hasn’t really attracted a lot of attention. As it turns out, Chris did not in fact get the talent in the family... and neither did she, so don't ask me where it went. But we’ll go into more depth about that when we come to it. Suffice to say that’s the one part of the book I’m least looking forward to tackling.

Part one of the book is called The Fork, and the title page has an okay drawing of a fork on it, done by Paolini himself. I do however feel like I should mention that it has three tines. Medieval forks only had two.
 


I’m just saying it could have been an opportunity to demonstrate some research and realism, but nope. Whatever.

I am not looking forward to the fork.

There’s also a really ugly, garishly coloured map that looks like it was done in crayon by a small child.

For now let’s start at the beginning, well known as a very good place to start, and we do at least start in a familiar place – with Eragon being a whiny asswipe. Truly, it was an excellent tactic for making longtime readers feel at home, sigh…

Chapter one opens with Eragon drinking “blackberry mead” and mentally whining about how he misses Carp Hat before moving on to whining about how the dwarf ambassador guy, Hruthmund, is annoying him by not delivering supplies frequently enough. You’re not giving me free shit at a fast enough rate! How dare you!

How goddamn entitled can you get?

Apparently Ergy’s new digs are called “the Academy”, and having established that he moves on to… complaining even more! He looks at the paperwork all over his desk and bitches about how he’s so busy, baww. Then get some subordinates to help you, you idiot! At the very least, shut the hell up! Christ. 

After that Ergy looks out the window and we get some description of the landscape below before Paolini starts trying to show off what a linguistic genius he is yet again as we get an infodump about how the mountain they’re building on has a bunch of different names in different languages, all of them suitably pretentious. Probably the most painful one is the elvish one (of course), which means “hope”. Because, you know, “the Dragon Riders were a hope for all the races of Arglegargle”.

Ah yes, the uber-powerful order of tyrants who wrecked half the country fighting among themselves and were brought back by a murderous sociopath who slaughtered his way through half a dozen cities, burning slums and allowing his underlings to put heads on pikes and torture prisoners along the way. I can definitely see why people would find the likes of him inspiring.

Eragon then goes back to bitching and moaning, and in an historic moment the elves are actually honest to god criticised. He even thinks that he finds them the most frustrating to deal with.

More whining and complaining ensues, and we learn that Ergy’s so stressed out he’s losing weight. Don’t ask me why I should care.

After that comes – oh dear lord even more complaining. Boohoo he doesn’t want to have to deal with paperwork all day, boohoo he wishes he could fly off and have adventures with Saphira (when at any point did he have “adventures” in the previous books?). He even fantacises about using magic to destroy the mean ole paperwork.

At this point Saphira shows up and tells him he’s done enough and should get some R&R, to which he replies that “there isn’t anyone else who can do it but me”.

Oh yeah, because Eragon is an expert on governing people and administering a settlement.

Or not. I’m not sure if this is blindingly arrogant or just stupid.

What am I saying – it’s both.

Saphira tells him to shut up and then tells him he’s not himself. Oh really? How is endlessly whining and complaining while acting like an entitled buffoon anything at all unusual for him?

In the end she wins the argument and Ergy stomps off. Paolini still has no idea how to make his hero likeable, I see.

Ergs walks through the building, and we get some description of how everything’s super big to make room for dragons and also there are storerooms, etc. He enters a courtyard where a couple of urgals are wrestling, and then sees a couple of elves who get names for no reason before going into a big main hall and then checking out some stores, and complaining even MORE about how he’s overworked. Again, there’s no reason given why he can’t just delegate. Hire some secretaries for gods’ sakes! I’m starting to get the feeling he just flat-out doesn’t respect anyone else enough to entrust them with anything.

Finally he goes into the room where they’re keeping the Eldunari. Yet again Paolini fails to use the plural “Eldunarya” which he once specified in an interview. Is… is he delegating the interviews to someone else? Or is he delegating the writing to someone else and just doing the kiss-ass interviews?

Anyway, we learn that the Eldunarya here are mostly the ones Egy looted from the Vault of Souls, but some of the “mad” ones he got off Galby are here too. The rest are all underground out of harm’s way. We learn that Ergy wanted to keep all all them underground along with the eggs, but the eldunarya said no.

Thanks to the eldunarya and the fancy crystal windows it’s always really colourful in here, and having thought about that Ergy goes to chat with Glaedr. Glaedr asks him what’s up, and on being told that Ergs is stressed out offers up some clichéd platitudes about centering yourself, blah blah. Umaroth joins in the conversation and says he needs some distraction, adding that they have the power to show Ergy stuff that’s happening elsewhere. Ergy says okay, so they start showing him visions, and the chapter ends on this cliffhanger.
 

We now cut to chapter two, and the POV of some random kid called Essie. Apparently it’s “two days past Maddentide”. I have absolutely no idea what Maddentide is, and Google had nothing for me other than some advertising for designer shoes.

As for our new protag, she’s – what else? – sulking. Apparently she’s had some kind of falling out with a couple of other kids, one of whom she pushed into a trough. This is all going down in Ceunon, ie the city the elves slaughtered in the main series for having the gall to cut down trees, and we get an infodump about how Essie’s family leaves out offerings of milk and bread for “the Svartlings”. Which is another piece of lore dropped in out of nowhere which will not be explained.

Blah blah, descriptions of the fish market, Essie reaches a tavern called (groan) the Fulsome Feast, which has pretty windows made out of crystal (you wot?). Her dad is inside working at the bar, and there’s a guy sitting by the fire who’s obviously a traveller, and who gets a chunk of description – don’t ask me why because Essie “didn’t care” and thinks he’s just another traveller so whatever. Then why did you pay enough attention to him to give us all that description of him, kid?

Our heroine gets some food and sits down to eat it in a sulk. What is this – Temper Tantrums: The Novel?

The traveller guy asks her what’s up, and for absolutely no reason Essie decides to tell this random stranger about how she hates some other kid called Hjordis. Again for no reason, the random guy asks to hear about it chapter and verse. And, like most of Paolini’s protagonists, he talks in the most pretentious and stilted manner possible. Essie thinks that he talks “as if he were sculpting the air with his tongue”.

Ewwww. 

After that she suddenly starts acting like a five year old, bouncing her feet around and childishly saying she can’t confide in him unless they’re friends and that if he tells her his name that will make them friends.

Has Paolini ever met a child before?

Anyway, the guy gives his name as “Tornac”, and for no reason Paolini feels the need to tell us how his nails are trimmed.

Seriously. Don’t ask me why the bizarre fingernail fetish carried over from the last book, but apparently it has.

Also, it’s now pretty obvious that this guy is Murtagh.

Don’t ask me why, but Totally Not Murtagh is all too happy to sit there and listen to the kid bitch about how Hjordis is “mean” and encourages other kids to pick on her. And then Paolini compares him to a cat, because clearly that’s the only thing he knows how to compare a character to.

To cut an extremely boring story short, the bully Hjordis manipulated our whiny heroine into pushing a friend of hers into a horse trough. Thankfully the pulse-pounding excitement of all this is interrupted by Essie’s dad, and Not-Murtagh pays him off to keep a table clear because he’s expecting company.

Unfortunately once he’s left Not-Murtagh asks for more detail. Or rather he asks “Was that the full accounting?”, because that’s just how Paolini does dialogue. Essie wails about how now her friends won’t like her any more, even if she apologises, to which Not-Murtagh says “Then maybe they weren’t really your friends”.

Well, that’s definitely something Murtagh would understand given how his own “friend” Eragon treated him.

Finally Essie declares that she’s going to run away from home. Oh, and Murtagh’s “eyebrows climbed toward his hairline”. And that is one truly horrible piece of description.

After some more blah blah in which Not-Murtagh plays around with his fork, he notices the burn scar on Essie’s arm and tells her he should be proud of it “Because a scar means you survived. It means you’re tough and hard to kill. It means you lived. A scar is something to admire”.

Well that’s a rather large change of tune after all the boo-hooing about how terrible scars are in the last four books. (And it will be completely disregarded by the end of the story anyway).

Further blah-blah ensues about how she got the scar (an accident involving boiling water), Essie asks Not-Murtagh about where he’s from, and finally the monotony is broken up by the arrival of a guy with a creepy voice. He also looks ugly and wears ragged clothes, so you know he’s Evil. Essie immediately decides she doesn’t like him, so yep – Evil.

The dude is introduced as Sarros, and he’s brought some obvious goons with him.

Murtagh, the fucking idiot, actually insists that Essie sit in on the conversation. Because that definitely won’t compromise your privacy and potentially put the kid in danger, will it? Couldn’t Paolini have just had her eavesdrop, at the very least?

Sarros tells Murtagh “I’ll not argue, even if you put your foot crosswise”, whatever the hell that means, and then gives him a chunk of rock. Except it has “a deep shine” and smells like sulphur.  He explains that he found it in some unspecified place along with a bunch of others which were all burned but with “no sign of flame or smoke”. He then smiles creepily, and we learn that he has teeth filed into points.

Ten bucks says he’s a Shade.

Murtagh pays the guy, and demands more information, but in a plot twist which would be shocking to anyone who’s never watched a movie before the obviously shady Sarros suddenly announces that he and his goons are going to rob him instead. And then – shock of shocks – he takes Essie hostage with a knife at her throat.

Gosh, who would have thought inviting a kid to sit in on a meeting with obvious bad guys would end badly for said kid? Nice work, Morontagh.

This being Paolini, he proceeds to emotionlessly exposit that Essie is, like, scared and whatever. Oh no. I might get hurt. Woe is me.


"I'm like scared and whatever. Where's my fifty bucks?"
 

Murtagh briefly attempts to negotiate, and then says some magic words. Sarros busts out a random amulet and says neener neener he’s protected against magic, so Murtagh uses “the Word” to render that null and void, which doesn’t work, whereupon Essie’s “Papa” randomly realises what’s going on and rushes in like an idiot, only to be bashed over the head.

Essie, being a Paolini character, reacts to this with more half-hearted description about how totally scared and upset she is. Totally. Believe me!


"Oh no. Woe is me. I'm so upset I just can't even. Where's my fifty bucks?"
 

God Paolini sucks at writing emotions.

Murtagh is still fiddling with the fork (where’s the unbreakable magic sword, you stupid dickhead?), and this is where it gets really stupid. The more so given that it’s clearly supposed to be “cool” and “badass”.

He casts a spell over the fork, then uses it to disarm Sarros and hold him at, uh, forkpoint, and makes a “cool” quip about how he can still cast spells over other things, “Like this fork, for example”. Sarros shoves Essie away, and she’s, like, totally scared and whatever and crawls away, after which she watches Murtagh – groan – kill some baddies with the fork. Supposedly he looks totally cool and badass while he does this, with “amazing skill”. Then one goon decides to attack Essie for… no reason, and then drops dead because Murtagh threw the fork and impaled him in the back of the head with it.

There is no way in hell any fork would have tines long enough to penetrate that far into the skull. Paolini still needs to stop basing his fight scenes on stupid action movies from the 80s.

Sarros throws some random “glittering crystals” at Murtagh, who uses the Word to divert them into the fireplace where they explode. He then uses Super Strength™ to bodyslam Sarros into the floor before interrogating him. Sarros tells him he’s “moon-addled and nose-blind”.

Nose-blind? Paolini’s just pulling words out of a hat now, isn’t he?

Anyway, so then Sarros starts spewing a bunch of random stuff about “the sleeper” and “the Dreamers”, and then has some sort of fit and dies.

Well that was… random.

Paolini suddenly remembers Essie is supposed to be our POV character, because he throws in some more uninterested exposition about how she’s scared and whatever and how the world is a scarier place than she realised alas and whatever.

Murtagh gets his stuff back and gives Essie’s dad some money to pay for the damages, and then pulls the fork out of the dead guy’s head before making a little speech to Essie about how running away isn’t always an option and sometimes you have to stand and fight and now do you understand that. Obvious moral is obvious.

He then gives the fork to Essie, saying she should use it on Hjordis. Lovely.

Naturally our heroine accepts it and proves to be just as much of a sociopath as all the rest of Paolini’s protagonists because, immediately after multiple violent deaths and having almost died herself, she “adorably” and “hilariously” names the fork Mister Stabby (seriously), then gets all smiley and happy about having a cool new weapon.

Apparently shock isn’t a thing that exists in Arglebarg, even for small children.

Murtagh is asked the old dramatic chestnut “who are you, really?”, and answers that he’s “Just another person looking for answers”, after which he randomly and for no reason uses magic to remove Essie’s scar. Because, you know, scars are cool and badass and whatever but you don’t want to look ugly, do you?

And then Essie starts crying.

Not because she almost died. Not because her dad almost died. Not because she just witnessed multiple violent deaths.

Nope, she cries because now she’s not ugly any more.

Like I said: sociopath.

We then cut to Murtagh’s POV as he leaves. He thinks about how he hasn’t killed people in a while, then gets all prissy and disgusted because there’s some blood on him. Shouldn’t you be used to that sort of thing by now, Murty?

Thorn contacts him mentally, asking if he’s okay, and this is his only contribution to the story, after which Arya’s grass ship randomly shows up. Murtagh watches it flying around for a bit, and then Has Emotions about how maybe he should go back to “old friends”. What old friends? Supposedly Eragon and Nausea “vigorously” defend him but pretty much everyone still hates him anyway, which is why he’s going by the most obvious pseudonym on earth and has apparently used magic to disguise his face.

He then moves on to looking at the random amulet he got from Sarros, and wonders how it protected him from the Name of Names before deciding to go have a chat with the “witch-woman” the guy claimed to have got it from.

And the story ends there.

Well that was a waste of time. And yet again Paolini hints at something interesting before choosing to focus on something completely boring and irrelevant instead. Who cares about some random innkeeper’s daughter who will probably never appear again, and why would Murtagh want to hang out with a random kid anyway? It doesn’t help that Essie is a dull and unlikable character to begin with; literally all she does in the entire story is whine and sulk and then act like a sociopath. Couldn’t we have seen Murtagh investigating the weird burned rocks and having an adventure instead? He’s one of the most powerful guys around and the best we get is a barfight with an uninteresting and extremely clichéd minor villain.

The chapter ends there, and we won’t be seeing Murtagh again or learn anything further about whatever it is he’s investigating. Boo!
 

The next chapter returns to Doucheagon, reacting to the boring story he just witnessed. He’s inexplicably glad to have seen Murtagh, and thinks about how “He deserves to be happy”. Apparently our supposed hero has conveniently forgotten all about his previous attitude toward the guy. Murtagh gets enslaved by Galby and is forced to serve him? Boo hiss you are teh ebilness!!1 But the moment Galby’s dead it’s all happy happy joy joy smile on your brother best friends 4 eva, etc. The abrupt heel-turn is incredibly jarring, and just makes Ergy look like an asshole who only thinks of you as a friend or even a relative if you’re serving his interests.

He then moves on to thinking about whatever it is Murty is investigating, and then – oh dear lord, apparently the whole thing was about teaching Ergy an Important Moral too, because he thinks about what Murtagh said to Essie, and then reflects how if a kid like that can face her problems so can he because he’s, like, a big important Dragon Rider and stuff. Barf.

Glaedr asks if that helped, and Ergy says yeah thanks and leaves. It’s nighttime outside so we get some description of the stars and a recap about how Arya created the grass ship Murtagh saw before Ergy goes back to Saphira. She tells him “You’re much nicer when you’re not snapping like an angry fox”.

I disagree. Even when he’s not in a temper Eragon is not a nice person. He’s boring, he’s arrogant, he’s entitled, he’s judgemental and smug, he’s needlessly violent and cruel, he’s callous, he’s utterly incurious and dull, he has no empathy, he’s apathetic, he’s an egotist, he’s breathtakingly selfish, megalomaniac, monumentally stupid and intellectually lazy, racist, sexist, a stalker and a creeper, a hypocrite who pretends to revere life while gorging on meat and revelling in the unnecessary slaughter of sentient beings… I can go on.

Moving on, he shows Saphira what he saw earlier and she says it’d be nice if Murtagh and Thorn came and joined them. I disagree with that as well; you just know Ergy would take it as an opportunity to abuse the pair of them in a hundred subtle ways.

Saphira asks if he thinks they have “another enemy hidden in Algalbloom”, and Eragon responds with what amounts to who cares and let’s not think about it before going to sleep “snuggled” against her. Don’t ask me how that’s the slightest bit comfortable, but I see our hero’s track record of being apathetic and incurious remains intact.

 

Date: 2019-10-13 04:04 pm (UTC)
redwyvernheart: (Default)
From: [personal profile] redwyvernheart
It is really amazing how much better Consequence is than the canon. For being spite-fiction Consequence is at least respectful to the main characters and doesn't go out of its way to write them in a bad light. I really wanted to see Eragon and Arya's relationship shown though mirror talking and their dragons excited by the thought of seeing each other. If this book was not going have any major events it should have had at least character growth. The only nice touch was the grass boat.

Murtagh’s plot was awful. Once again Consequence did it better with him and Thorn living in isolation, caring for those in need, and even asking for permission to help which showed how much of their freewill was taken from them and how they refuse to impose themselves on others.

As children well I feel like if your going add a child to the plot they should grow into an important character and not be annoying. Example Red from The Risen Sun. Essie though...She just adds nothing. Delete her from existence. I won't waste my time trying to think of ways to fix her character.

Lastly the Eldunarya are actually shown here but it feels awkward/forced. First off shouldn't helping them be the number one priority. Some of them are still trapped in madness. The eggs are important too but they will hatch (expect for the poor spellbound eggs those need partners fast to end their suffering).
As for the eldunarya I would almost like to see them helped in steps. First counseling. 2) Helping them manifest themselves like ghost dragons. (Imagine a city of ghost dragons running around) and move things with ghost powers 3) Become a different type of creature (think leveling up), be reborn as eggs, or just ask to be crushed. Just something. In Lost Girl "Valkyries can become pregnant and carry the fetus to term, but they die in childbirth. Upon a Valkyrie's last death they disintegrate into particles of light. These particles of light coalesce into the shape of a Valkyrie with her wings and ascends into the sky. The end of their last life is called a "rising" . Their ultimate fate after the rising remains unknown."
Also why are none of the eldunarya related to Saphira, Thorn, etc or even just talking about being partnered to a relevant rider. Even at the end of the book (sorry I am skipping) were was Vêrmund's eldunaryi to explain his side of things if he was a dragon that actually existed. Really one of the most interesting dragons who could have been eldunaryi would have been Saphira 1.


Edited Date: 2019-10-13 10:47 pm (UTC)

Date: 2019-10-13 08:17 pm (UTC)
torylltales: (Default)
From: [personal profile] torylltales
Essie thinks that he talks “as if he were sculpting the air with his tongue”.

EWWWWW

Date: 2019-10-13 09:09 pm (UTC)
From: (Anonymous)
Hello! This is the first time I comment because my English is very bad. Of course I apologize for mistakes in this comment, I only have a dictionary, the google translator and my little knowledge of English ... in short, I have read the inheritance cycle spork and really enjoy them. I have too much hate for Paolini and I also wrote reviews in his time, although I never published them.
Regarding this grouting of words (sincerely it hurts to consider it a book) I can only say that I agree. It's bullshit. There is no progress in anything, neither in history, nor in the world, nor in character.

I have to highlight something, it must be the first time I read that a Paolini character tries to avoid violence as a first option and even gives the other guy a chance to take the money and leave ... of course not achieved, because it is always better to have a completely ridiculous "action" scene (please read the sarcasm in the last sentence). But it's not such a bad contrast, after seeing that in the last book, Eragon and Roran, and everyone ... reacted with death threats even with allies or guys who hadn't even done anything to him. I am sure that the simple fact that i notice this as something rare in paolini is wrong. Violence should never be the first option "type heroes."

I am not sure of the material of the fork, but it sure was a metal, and with sufficient force and especially speed (given by magic) it could work as a bullet, so if I could pierce the man. is not that this detail Avoid the stupidity of the whole thing. So meh

I will admit that I also skipped several parts of the book (Total don't buy it) and That's why I saved myself from several of Eragon's moron complaints.
I really do not care, I just read some of this grout to enjoy more of these spork (truth be told)

The whole affair with essie or whatever, was ridiculous. Paolini finally understood that part of his fans are only there because they want to read something from Murtagh, and he ruins it again giving us such an insignificant scene. he really let the girl stay ... I'm going to think that Murty is not in her right mind for so much mental looting ... and then he gives her a gun ... to prick another girl ... WHAT IS YOUR CURSE PROBLEM, PAOLINI?

I laughed a lot when I read the "healthy relationship" of Eragon and Saphira. These two barely tolerate each other, I could see more concern and affection in the non-existent conversation of Murty and Thorn, than in all the time of Saphira and Eragon together. That is not a healthy relationship.

But, to my regret, I have to admit that I liked the detail of the little boat and that Murtagh used the name Tornac as a pseudonym. I think that he must be the only one who has his father figure in mind (even if in a minimal way) throughout the series. Seriously, that bothered me a lot in the series called INHERITANCE CYCLE. Neither Eragon, nor Roran, nor Arya, nor Nasuada think of their families more than for two seconds and then goodbye. Not even Katrina, after everything Sloan did for her!!
Nor does it bother me that Murty heals the scar of the girl, he can do it and nobody really wants a scar (There are people who take off moles for aesthetics), it is also just a girl, sociopath, But girl after all. However, if it bothers me that the girl cried for that, but not for the possible death of her father and even herself.
In conclusion, Paolini is still a moron, and the reason he will never improve as a writer is that he is not even willing to mature as a human being. I don't want to be rude, but I think I can be a little bit, and that is that paolini looks more like a robot than a human. He is a child in an adult body and if he is allowed to continue publishing after this horrible saga that only serves to criticize, laugh at him and make fanfics (and there are some that are even worse than the original) it is because the world is idiot and has no hope.
I regret that it is such a long comment, never comment anything, and now only everything accumulated came out. And I regret my mistakes in the language. As I said, I really enjoy reading this page, and I look forward to the next post.

Date: 2019-10-14 10:46 am (UTC)
minionnumber2: (Default)
From: [personal profile] minionnumber2
I think that map is colored pencil. At least, it looks similar to the results I get when I try my Prismacolors.

Paolini's had this fork scene in his head for a while. Apparently he thought the idea was so amusing he just had to include it. I think he also realized that having Murtagh name the fork Mr. Stabby would be out of character, so he added in someone who's humor matched his own.

Date: 2019-10-14 02:46 pm (UTC)
oblakom: (Default)
From: [personal profile] oblakom
Oooh, gods, this makes me glad we didn't have Murtagh's pov in the Cycle. Paolini has this amazing ability of turning every character into an unbearable idiot or into a sociopath.

Here we had a chapter with Murtagh (even if not pov) and he already acts OOC.

Also, someone should slap Eragon in the face. I am sorry for that poor egg that hatchesnat the end of the book.

...Love how Eragon's comfort remains priority n°1, God forbid he gets tired doing what is his responsibility.

Date: 2019-10-21 12:02 pm (UTC)
gharial: (Default)
From: [personal profile] gharial
That random amulet that makes the wearer 100% immune to magic on a fundamental level seems like a really frigging big deal. Galbatorix's whole deal was that he was a powerful magician. He'd be helpless against anyone wearing that (well, he'd have Shuriken but fat lot of good that does him in the main story). And if Galby himself had it, Eragon wouldn't have been able to kill him the way he did. Really feels like something like this should have been mentioned earlier, either as an ancient relic or as a theoretical way to approach using wards. At least Paolini does something to note its significance. Still, it seems way too useful to just show up in the possession of some random bandit.

Date: 2019-10-23 11:22 am (UTC)
ssbob90: kurnous (Default)
From: [personal profile] ssbob90
Here we have eragon. A farmboy who spent years toiling in the field and suffering from winter and drought, tiring himself to make sure he can eat, and having to to grit his teeth through hard time and prepare for the next.

Currently whining like a spoiled prince whose dessert came a minutes late. And have to learn a lesson of going through hardship, something a farmer most likely learned, from a child, and he is about twenty mind you. What do you mean he was a farmboy. It's obvious Paolini had little knowledge of farming, at least in the middle age.

But I have a headcanon. When eragon goes hunting he is lying. In reality it's an excuse to not do farmwork, leaving it to Garrow and roran, and just lays around the spine before returning and boasting of capturing beast he couldn't show. It at least explain why he has fats that was gone in book 1.
Edited Date: 2019-10-23 11:25 am (UTC)

Date: 2019-10-26 05:10 pm (UTC)
snarkbotanya: My spitefic character Vanora as she appears in later chapters post-haircut, looking annoyed. (Default)
From: [personal profile] snarkbotanya
"Apparently it’s “two days past Maddentide”. I have absolutely no idea what Maddentide is, and Google had nothing for me other than some advertising for designer shoes."

That would be Paolini trying to BS some worldbuilding.

"What is this – Temper Tantrums: The Novel?"

It's a Paolini book, so... yes. Yes, it is.

"Naturally our heroine accepts it and proves to be just as much of a sociopath as all the rest of Paolini’s protagonists because, immediately after multiple violent deaths and having almost died herself, she “adorably” and “hilariously” names the fork Mister Stabby (seriously), then gets all smiley and happy about having a cool new weapon."

Wait, he made Essie call it Mr. Stabby? Damn, the setup would have actually made it semi-reasonable for Murtagh to name the fork Mr. Stabby as a way of trying to make the scared kid laugh. Instead, it just makes Essie a miniature psycho.

We then cut to Murtagh’s POV as he leaves. He thinks about how he hasn’t killed people in a while, then gets all prissy and disgusted because there’s some blood on him.

Hello, character derailment... Murtagh was never prissy about that kind of thing in the Cycle, and he won't be in Consequence.

Profile

antishurtugal_reborn: (Default)
Where the Heart of Anti-Shurtugal Rises Again.

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  12 3 45
6 78 9 10 1112
1314 151617 18 19
20 212223 24 2526
27 28293031  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 29th, 2025 06:18 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios